Two weeks into a stucco re-clad in Coquitlam, the north wall comes off and the plywood under the kitchen window crumbles in a gloved hand. Nobody on site did anything wrong. That wall had been taking water through a failed sill flashing since the late 1990s, behind a finish that looked fine from the driveway. What happens next is a change order, and how that change order gets handled decides whether the project ends with a handshake or a dispute over the final invoice.
Change orders on an exterior renovation in BC are close to certain on any house built before rainscreens became standard. So the useful question for an owner is how hidden conditions will be handled once they appear. That gets settled in writing before the contract is signed, or it gets settled later at a much worse moment.
How are change orders for hidden conditions handled on a BC exterior renovation?
A change order is a written amendment to the contract that adds or removes work and states its price and schedule effect. When the crew opens a wall and finds hidden conditions such as rotted sheathing or framing, they stop on that section, photograph and measure it, and send you a priced change order. Work there continues once you sign. Fair pricing uses unit rates agreed before the contract, for example $180 to $350 per sheet of sheathing replaced.
What counts as a hidden condition
A hidden condition is one that a careful contractor could not see or reasonably expect from the walk-through and any test openings done before pricing. Wet sheathing behind intact stucco qualifies. So does a rotted rim joist behind a deck ledger, a window installed with no sill flashing at all, or a sheathing membrane lapped the wrong way in 1994 that has been steering water inward ever since. On most re-clads the first elevation is stripped by the end of week one or two, and that is when these conditions surface.
A lot of what owners get billed as "hidden" fails that test. Cracks you can see from the sidewalk, rust staining under a window, a bulge at the base of a wall, a moisture reading your contractor took and then ignored: all of that was visible before anyone signed. If an estimate priced a simple recoat over a wall showing those signs, the change order that follows belongs to the contractor.
The documents draw the line between the two. On a house, that means the estimate's list of assumptions. A good one states what the price assumes about the wall, for example "sheathing sound except as noted at test openings 1 to 4", so anything worse is plainly a change and anything at those openings is already priced. On a strata or commercial building, the envelope consultant's report and specification draw the line, which is one reason to read what a building envelope consultant report should include before the tender goes out.
What a proper change order contains
A change order is a short document. These are the parts that matter, and a missing one is where most arguments start:
- what was found, located by elevation and opening
- photographs taken before anything is removed or repaired
- the quantity, counted on site (sheets, stud bays, linear feet of flashing)
- the price, built from the agreed unit rates or broken into labour and materials
- the schedule effect in working days, even when the answer is zero
- whether a permit revision or an engineer's review is needed
- signatures from both sides before the work proceeds
Photographs matter more than owners expect. Once new sheathing is on and wrapped, the evidence is gone, and a change order without photos asks you to pay for something you will never see.
The most common mistake we see owners make is approving a change on the scaffold. The foreman points at the rot, the owner says go ahead, and the price arrives three weeks later on an invoice with no count and no photos. Saying yes on the spot feels cooperative. It also leaves you with nothing to check the bill against, and most of the disputes we hear about from other people's projects start exactly there.
Turnaround is the other half. A change order for routine sheathing and framing repair should reach the owner the same day the damage is counted, and a signature within a day or two keeps the job on schedule. The crew keeps working on other elevations in the meantime, and the open section stays covered with temporary membrane. In November that cover is not optional: an open wall left exposed over a wet weekend takes on water the repair then has to deal with.
How change orders get priced
There are three ways to price a change, and the contract should say which one applies to which kind of work.
Unit rates are the cleanest way to handle hidden conditions that repeat. In Greater Vancouver right now that means roughly $180 to $350 per sheet of plywood sheathing replaced and $400 to $900 per stud bay of framing repair. The rate is agreed before anyone knows the quantity, so the only thing left to settle on site is the count, and you can stand there and count with the crew. We cover how to line those rates up between bidders in our guide to comparing exterior renovation bids.
A quoted lump sum suits the one-off discovery: a garage door header that an engineer has to size, a chimney chase framed without fire blocking, a deck ledger that has to come off and be re-flashed. The contractor prices that specific fix and you approve it before the crew touches it.
Time and materials is the method of last resort, for work whose extent nobody can know until it is underway. The contract should already set the hourly rate for each trade and the markup on materials and subcontractors. A markup of 10 to 20 percent over direct cost is the usual range on extras in BC; ask about anything higher before you sign. Time-and-materials work should also carry a not-to-exceed figure that gets revisited in writing if the crew approaches it.
A typical change order, worked through
Take a 1990s two-storey house with face-sealed stucco, about 2,200 square feet of wall, being re-clad in fibre cement over a rainscreen cavity. The contract price is $105,000 and carries unit rates for sheathing and framing. The owner holds a 12 percent contingency, about $12,600, outside the contract.
In week two the north and east elevations come off. The crew finds this:
| Hidden condition | Quantity | Pricing | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soft or delaminated sheathing below two windows and along the deck | 16 sheets | Unit rate, $260 per sheet | $4,160 |
| Rot at the bottom plate under the kitchen window | 4 stud bays | Unit rate, $650 per bay | $2,600 |
| Deck ledger with no flashing, rotted rim board behind it | 1 location | Quoted lump sum | $3,400 |
| Total | $10,160 |
That is about 9.7 percent of the contract, inside the contingency, with four working days added to the schedule. It went to the owner as two change orders on consecutive days, photographs attached, and the north elevation was closed in by the end of the week.
The same discovery handled badly looks different. With no unit rates in the contract, the contractor prices the damage after the fact, the owner has nothing to compare it against, and the deck ledger gets "fixed" with a bead of sealant because nobody wanted the conversation. That is the real cost of a contract that makes change orders painful. Hidden conditions get covered up instead of repaired, and they come back as the next owner's problem.
An exterior renovation on a pre-2000 house that finishes with zero change orders should worry you more than one with three or four. Either the base price was padded to absorb whatever turned up, or damage got closed back in.
Strata and commercial projects: the consultant sits in the middle
On multi-family and commercial work the process is more formal, and council members should know how it runs before they put a levy to owners.
Most strata and commercial envelope projects in BC are tendered on a specification written by a building envelope consultant, and many use the CCDC 2 stipulated-price contract or a version of it. CCDC 2 has a clause for concealed or unknown conditions (GC 6.4). The party who finds them gives written notice before the conditions are disturbed, and no later than five working days after first seeing them. The consultant reviews them on site, and if they differ materially from what the contract documents described, the price and schedule are adjusted through a change order.
When owner and contractor cannot agree on a price fast enough to keep the job moving, CCDC 2 allows a change directive. The owner instructs the contractor to proceed, and the value is settled afterward on actual cost plus an agreed fee. Directives keep the scaffold productive. Councils should use them sparingly, because a stack of unpriced directives in August turns into a budget meeting nobody planned for.
The money has its own rules. A special levy under the Strata Property Act needs a three-quarter vote, and council can spend only what owners approved, so going over usually means another general meeting and another vote. That is why a well-drafted levy resolution includes a contingency line, typically 10 to 15 percent of construction cost, and why councils often delegate approval of individual change orders below a set dollar figure to the property manager and the consultant. A $4,000 sheathing change order should not wait three weeks for the next council meeting.
As a building envelope contractor on Lower Mainland strata projects, we see the same pattern each season. The projects that run cleanly are the ones where unit rates, the delegation limit and the contingency were all settled before the scaffold went up.
The contingency, and the part you do not spend
Carry a contingency of 10 to 15 percent of the contract on any exterior renovation of a building put up before 2000, and plan for the top of that range or above it on face-sealed stucco from the late 1980s and 1990s. Keep it outside the contract price. A large allowance inside the contract tends to get spent; money the owner holds gets spent only against signed change orders.
Change orders also run the other way. If the contract carries an allowance and the actual repair comes in under it, the difference should come back to you as a credit change order. The same applies to scope you remove partway through, say a set of rear stairs you decide to leave for another year. Ask for each credit in writing when it happens.
One payment detail catches people. Under the BC Builders Lien Act, the owner holds back 10 percent of the value of work done, extras included, until 55 days after completion. Change orders add to the contract price, so they add to the holdback, and the final payment schedule should be revised to match.
Two change orders you can prevent before signing
Most hidden conditions stay hidden only because nobody looked. Two of the most expensive surprises on BC exteriors can be found before the contract.
The first is hazardous material. WorkSafeBC requires a hazardous materials survey before renovation or demolition on older buildings, which in practice means most houses built before 1990, and some older stucco and textured finishes contain asbestos. A survey on a house usually costs less than $1,500. Finding asbestos mid-demolition means stopping work, bringing in an abatement contractor and losing weeks, all of it billed as a change order.
The second is the extent of the damage itself. Invasive test openings where walls usually fail (window sills, deck connections, the base of the wall) cost roughly $700 to $1,400 each in the Lower Mainland including patching. Four to six of them on a house turn the biggest unknown into a measured quantity, and the estimate gets priced on what is in the wall. Our article on what a written estimate should include shows how those findings should flow into the price.
Permits sit right beside this. A recoat that turns into a strip to sheathing, or sheathing repair that becomes framing replacement, can move a project from no permit to needing one under the BC Building Code, or under the Vancouver Building By-law inside the city. A good change order flags that on the day it happens, so the permit revision runs in parallel with the work.
How we handle hidden conditions at MV Construction
MV Construction has priced and built exterior renovations across Greater Vancouver and Vancouver Island for 17+ years. We are fully licensed, insured and WCB-covered, our workmanship is warranty-backed, and every estimate we write carries unit rates for the hidden conditions we expect on that building type, from 1990s stucco houses in Coquitlam and Surrey to older strata buildings in Burnaby and on the North Shore. Every change order reaches the owner in writing, with photographs and a schedule effect, and nothing we find gets closed back in without a signature.
If you are planning a re-clad or envelope repair for spring and want to see how hidden conditions will be handled before any wall comes off, call (778) 375-5672 or request a fixed-scope written estimate.



